Thursday, February 18, 2016

Close Only Counts...

"Close Only Counts in Horseshoes and Hand Grenades" 

בס"ד
The day finally arrived.  It would mark 15 years of my journey with many different etchings.  When I think back to those days, the saying "Close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades" comes to mind.  I walked so close to what I felt I belonged to and yet so far away.  I had to learn that Messianic Judaism is not Judaism.  That realization took time to reach.

When I walked into the Messianic church, Roeh Israel, a week before Rosh Hashana in 1992, I thought that I came home.  Finally, I could learn Judaism and still be a Christian.  Or so I thought.  I had so much to learn and to work through.

It is strange to think back on those years.  Every week, there were more questions to ask.  Every week there were more prayers to learn, more books to read, more Hebrew to learn, more, more, more.  Reaching satiety and satisfaction wasn't happening.  The more I learned, the more I was challenged with questions.  After a while, Roeh was not a place to stay. They could only take me so far and no further.

So, I graduated to the infamous Adat Chaim in Fort Collins.  Yes, the nefarious place that sends many Jews into fits to hear the name.  And I cannot blame them.  Yes, I was there when the scandal happened that shook the world of conversion and put it on hold.  I was also there when the group closed and disbanded.  Yes, it was mostly a family scandal that closed Adat's doors.  Yes, I was there and it is a part of how I came to where I am today.

My part and several of my friend's part in being at Adat apparently was to be a thorn in their flesh.  You know, the proverbial pain in the tukis.  We were insatiable and had unending questions mixed with a need to be Jewish.  Often we would say things like, "If we are Jewish, then why don't we cover our hair if we are married women?" "If we are Jewish, then why are we going out to eat?" "If we are Jewish, then why are we skipping most of the prayers?"  If we are Jewish...if...if...if.

By the end of the 15 years, most of my friends had left the Messianics and either became Benei Noach or converted.  Others left because they could not stand how Jewish we were becoming. They either went back to the church or became completely secular.  I almost left 2 1/2 years before I could make the final break.  That day stands out as shocking to even myself.

After studying Greek and Hebrew and comparing the Christian text to the Jewish one, I had enough.  There are so many changes made in the Christian text. They screamed out saying that something was seriously wrong.  What drove the nail in the coffin was reading Josh McDowell's book Evidence that Demands a Verdict. In the beginning of his book, he spoke of hundreds of changes made in the Christian text versus the one letter change in the Hebrew text: an aleph to an ayin.  I was horrified.  Here was a leading apologist proving his own chosen religion was full of holes and problems.  As I read further into his book, there were more and more excuses he made for his religion.  He wasn't defending it.  He was excusing it.  Add this to the misgivings and questions I was having that came from reading writings from Jews like Rabbi Areyah Kaplan, ז"ל, and Rabbi Bar Tzaddok, and I became quite livid about being lied to for so long and for having believed the lie.

I had enough.  I could not just walk away.  Oh no.  I believed that these people who helped me through hell and back, deserved to know why I was leaving and not coming back.  I was off to services for one last time, or so I thought. It was in January 2006. Services were over.  Lunch eaten.  Time to learn.  I took my Christian text over to the leader, Danny Miller, threw it down on the floor, and firmly stated, "This text is full of nonsense. You had better defend it well or I am out of here."  The look of shock and horror on his and the other leader's faces.  The next few months were filled with reading the Christian text verse by verse and the leader "answering" all questions I asked.  Often, I told this leader that I could not accept his answer and he had better come up with a better one.

He never had a chance to do so.  Right after Pesach, he resigned.

That moment put leaving this group on the back burner.  Soon we saw who would stay and who would go.  A very small core of people remained.  We were very lost, hurt, and confused.  We fervently studied and learned.  So many questions.  So much hunger.  Such a desire to truly become Jewish.

The first Shabbat in Elul 5767/2007 I read the Torah portion, That portion struck me hard.  Torah doesn't change.  It was given to the leaders to make decisions as to how to live by it.  Who are those leaders?  The Rabbonim.  Their authority is so powerful that willfully choosing to not listen to them brings a harsh punishment. What the Rabbonim were saying was vastly different from what we were taught in the church.  Something in those words reached down and got me.  It was the final hammer blow that enabled me to say, "No more.  I cannot accept anything about Christianity.  I am finished.  If I am Jewish by birth like I think I am, I had better go home already.  No more messing around."

Wanting to say "Goodbye" to these friends who walked with me to this point, I returned.  I told them that I had to leave. I could no longer believe that this person, Yoshke, by whatever name anyone wanted to call him, was what he or his followers called him.  I could not believe he would return.  I could not accept the book attached to him nor the religion that was made by Paul with this man being the reason for it.

Instead of shocked looks, a collective sigh let out.  That same week others had made the same decision, but did not know how to tell the people in this small group.  Only one dear friend smiled and said, "Finally.  I gave this up years before but couldn't bring myself to leave." The rest of us took a little longer to get the spot she had reached previously.

A challenge arose. Now that we were at this point, what were we to do?  Most of us wanted to convert, but we were from THAT hated place. I thought I was Jewish and wasn't sure I could go to a synagogue with the history I had. So, began the page of feeling lost, in between and needing to find ourselves.

May we have the ability to know when close is as far apart as infinity.  May we have the courage to accept reality and turn our lives accordingly.


2 comments:

  1. Thanks. It is a bit surreal looking back at it. I do hope that sharing this will be helpful in some way.

    ReplyDelete