Monday, April 26, 2021

Exposing Missionaries

With the story of Michael Elkohen and his family being spread around and the Jewish world once again being shocked, perhaps it is time to tell my perspective and experiences on this topic.

I personally don't understand the shock that people feel everytime someone else is exposed.  Every time people say, "Missionaries are always trying to convert us.  But this one used new tactics", I think,  "No, they didn't".

I am reaching back 15 years to when I last studied this topic. I will try to relay what I know as briefly and accurately as I can. As this is a brief synopsis, it won't be a thorough retelling of the history that brought us to where we are, but hopefully it will paint enough of a picture to perhaps bring a little clarity on the matter.

At the Council of Nicaea, 325 CE, Emperor Constantine created a Catholic (Universal) Church. Jews and Christians were made into two clearly different religions. What the Christian Church would look like was defined in order for Constantine to attain this goal of a universal religion for his country.  

Replacement Theology, was strongly promoted by Martin Luther in the 1500's, as a result of his frustration with not being able to convert Jews. He spread the concept in Paul's teaching that a branch can be cut off a tree and grafted in. This meant that Christians replaced the Jews and Jews were no longer HaShem's chosen, ח"ו. 

Around 1810, a Russian immigrant whose name, if I recall correctly, was Rabinowitz, in the basement of a church in London, planted the idea of starting a group of Jewish Christians. Thus was born the London Society for Promoting Christianity Among the Jews.  Soon after, around 1866 Carl Schwartz, ran with the idea of promoting a combination of Jewish heritage and Christian theology. The Hebrew Christian Alliance of Great Britain was the result.  

In the 1890's they had periodicals circulating that made their way to America.  1915, The Hebrew Christian Society began in America.  In the 1960's, the first Messianic Churches began.  1980's they really took off. Around the 1990's, I watched several groups strive to become more Jewish than Christian. It wasn't enough to be a church that did Jewish things. 

The internet made it easy for them.  Resources were becoming readily available for people who already believed they were Jews and didn't understand why Jews wouldn't accept them.  The expressed concern from the 70 rabbis who were forced  by Ptolemy II Philadelpus around 250 BCE to translate our Torah into Greek came to fruition.  They knew and understood that with our Torah being translated into other languages and becoming more easily available, that people would misuse it and try to deceive us with our own Torah. People did run with it. They have done and do all sorts of things with our teachings. The trickery continues to develop over the centuries to match the times.

By the 1980's children and grandchildren were being born to these groups of Messianics.  Many began to believe wholeheartedly that they are Jews and that it is a tragedy that they are not accepted as Jews.  Ulpan on cassette was available to learn from.  Books were easy to access. Jews who had become apikores or rabbis who felt the urge to teach these eager Messianics were giving precious jewels to them.  The internet brought more direct teachings to their homes.  Around early 2000, I remember a school opening up to teach Messianics Hebrew, Yiddish, Talmud, Halacha, etc.  The people learning from these institutions quickly become indistinguishable from Chareidi Jews.

I fully left the Messianics in 2007.  I saw people from 1990's on sneak into the community undetected.  Most just wanted to be accepted as the Jews they believed they were.  They had no missionary intention.  But there were others...the mission oriented. Both are problematic in their own ways.

I did my part to become a "Missionary Hunter" when I was in conversion. One family I knew now lives in Haifa.  A friend and I did our part to bring evidence and expose them when they were trying to make Aliyah. We were met with a cease and desist order by the Rabbinut.  Our conversion rabbis apologized as they also saw what we did and knew that this needed to be dealt with. We did what we could. But our hands were tied. 

We then were put on a tricky task.  A Messianic group that preyed on Israelis and lesser educated Jews moved into our community.  We gathered information backed with pictures, emails, articles, etc.  But I was exposed as an informant in their circles. My life was threatened by a secondary situation we uncovered in process of looking at this one.  Thus ended my ability to help gather information by infiltration.  

After that, a lady wanted to be in conversion and was placed in the class I was in. She seemed off to me. I told my conversion rabbi who encouraged me to look into the matter. I found her interacting with a missionary group and took screenshots of these conversations where she was sharing information to a group in order to teach them.  She was an infiltrator.  My rabbi sent her away from conversion.  The rabbi whose synagogue she was a part of and we were doing classes at became upset with us.  We no longer could do classes there and I was told directly not to speak Lashon Hara against her, an "innocent" Jew.  I had direct evidence from her in writing and links for anyone to see what she was up to. Yet, I was not believed and she was.  

There are so many more stories and more rabbis who asked me to get information for them. When I gave direct source information to them, they chastised me and hung me out to dry. After a while, I gave up with exposing infiltrators.  The threats on my life and the unbelievable behavior of the rabbis was disgusting and not something I wanted to be involved in.

So no, the tactic that Michael Elkohen used is not new.  It is not surprising whatsoever.  A deceiver is a deceiver.  Otherwise, we wouldn't be deceived. Coercing us to convert didn't work. Pushing pamphlets didn't work. Becoming one of us, is a tantilizing prospect. They often believe they are Jews and should be treated as such. 

The availability of resources makes it easy for them to really learn what we know and do. And when they are exposed by someone who has firsthand information but no one is willing to listen, well... No, I am not surprised this happened.  

I am horrified knowing that when the shock wears off, another story will arise and people will again say, "How did this happen?" Instead of being caught off guard over and over, treat it like war.  Get into the mind of the enemy.  Learn what motivates them.  Figure out where they get their ammunition. Don't ignore warnings given.  Stop being caught off guard.  Expect that this will happen.  Understand they often believe they are Jews and are entitled to full rights as Jews. Know that they now have many generations of family.  It's not going away anytime soon.


2 comments:

  1. On the plus side, some of these groups are so hard core “into” Judaism that they inadvertently expose their members to too much Judaism which leads them to renounce the religion from that man entirely!

    Then they end up looking to actually convert.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don't we know that one well. Their plans backfired on them for sure!

      Delete