בס"ד
It has been 5 years since I made an entry in my blog. I stopped writing my story in March of 2016. People have asked me to write more. They wanted to know what happened post mikveh. I couldn't write. The pain was too near. I was afraid of what I was experiencing. A few times recently, I have been asked to pick up the pen and continue. To perhaps write something that could be published in a magazine. I've hesitated to do so as my story took turns that I am not sure would be looked kindly upon. But here I am, keyboard at my finger tips and my mind and heart flowing with so much to share. If you would permit me, this may not be events that happened but it certainly will be the impact that the events had on me. So the story continues.
I have observed many things and been marked deeply during this transformative time of awakening. Some leave me proud of the decision I made to join this family: the beauty of Shabbat, the deeply moving words of many prayers in our Siddur, the resilience in a world that attempts to snuff out the good we have to offer, the camaraderie of just being a Jew. Other things leave me repulsed, horrified, and broken hearted.
One thing I find appalling is how being stringent is equated with holiness. It is often stated that we do such and such as it is our custom and the custom of our fathers. Such customs are held to as if they were direct commands given to us from HaShem. Now there is nothing wrong with traditions. Every home and family has their own. It defines and creates a unique flavor for each group of people. Just like every tribe had their own set of strengths and deficiencies, so does each community of Jews. Each of us make up a picture of the whole, as indeed we should. But to hold to these traditions as if they were commanded to us by HaShem, that is a mistake. Often it takes us far from what HaShem wants from us.
Yet, who we have become as a result of adding stringency upon stringency, and the roles we have taken on in its wake have often paralyzed us from becoming who we are to be and realizing our potential as a whole. There are so many reasons for this. The one that has been standing out to me of late is a deplorable lack of curiosity. Who are we? Where do we come from? What is our history? Why do we do what we do? When will we realize how important it is to search out answers to these questions?
A story I often heard as a child comes to mind. It is of a child who visited his grandma. She was making a roast. She cut off the ends, put it in the roasting pan, and baked it. How delicious it was! Later, when at home, he observed his mom while she made a roast. She cut off then ends, put it in the roasting pan, and stuck it in the oven. Curious, he asked why she cut off the ends? Was there something wrong with them? Did it make the roast taste better to cut the ends off? She replied, "I make a roast this way because that is how my mother makes a roast and hers always turn out delicious." The boy was not satisfied and called his grandmother. "Grandma, why do you cut off the ends of the roast before putting it in the pan?" She replied, "Oh that? I buy a large roast to feed the family. But my pan is too small to fit it. So I cut off the ends so that it will fit."
The lesson held in that story makes me pause and consider, especially when I am not being curious enough and I am being told to follow what everyone else does. There seems to be no end to the list of dos and don'ts in the daily life of a Jew. Some are Torah mandates. Some are instituted by the Rabbonim. Some are customs. And some are chumrot. Their importance all weighs in differently. So few people know which is which and even less know how they came about. Rare is the one who seems to know how to apply a true Halacha to an individual situation. This is terrifying to me.
The beginning of Torah starts with an example and the end of Torah has a warning that should wake all of us up and stir a desire to learn where the things we do and value come from. Twice in Devarim (4:2 and 13:1) we are told not to add to or take from the words of Torah. In Bereshit, we are given the example of Chava adding a chumrah when she said not to touch the tree (3:3). We all know how that turned out. A deviation from Torah can lead us far from what HaShem intended and bring us straight into the arms of aveirot.
Another thing that I find appalling is the lack of curiosity about and education of our own history. We, as a people, must stir up a healthy curiosity that has been ignored for too long. We must learn our history. Who instituted certain things we did? What was happening at a particular time that motivated our leaders to create a particular ruling? Was such rulings for a particular time and place and were not meant to be carried on today? What is it that HaShem truly wants from us? Without asking these questions we have taken on far too much and have created a religion that is ultra fanatical and borders on lunacy. It has become something that is not plausible for people to maintain nor is it conducive for us to be healthy functioning members of society. I dare say, it is far from the sane, healthy way that HaShem wishes for us to live. The result is devastating. So many people run away as if fleeing a house on fire. Many who stay have lost a sense of self and live in deep depression. Others use it to lord over others and as a result drag people into self doubt and depression. The stringencies often separate family and friends. It creates poverty and sickness of both mind and body. This is not Judaism. Rather, such an approach to Judaism is a cult. It breaks my heart to see this. So many beautiful, well meaning people are drowning in the morass of harmful chumrot and don't even realize it.
There are those who ran out of the burning house, who said, "HaShem is one, Torah is true, and real Mitzvot are beautiful, but this unwarranted zealousness before us is death." We are often labeled "Off Derech" and are seen as ones to be cast away like a pariah. The anguish of soul that aches for Ahavat Israel and to no longer face such unrelenting and blind hate threatens to drive us away from any connection to HaShem, Torah, Mitzvot, and community. There is an encompassing comfort that enfolds and eases the pain when finding others with Yirat Shamayim who also encountered similar agony. As the healing embrace and the understanding companionship comforts a broken heart, light is restored and hope for a new beginning reawakens. No, those who ran from what is considered to be main stream Judaism to find a sane, healthy Judaism are not "Off Derech". Rather, our Yirat Shamayim drives us to continue with what we can and search to understand how we can heal and be better Jews. Often these journeys are alone and far from community. Often the cloak of religiousity is removed and many practices, good and not so good, are set down for a time while we rediscover HaShem and mitzvot. But our journey and the time to find what it means to be a Jew really entails are essential to our self discovery and growing into the individuals that HaShem created us to be.
From time to time, we look back. Our hearts hurt to see what sent us away. Often we long to somehow make a difference. Too often the how to accomplish that evades us. Sometimes, we see hope and perhaps a way to maybe make a positive impact. Sometimes our hands and voices are strengthened to do so. We become vessels of healing in those times. Accusations still fly but they affect us differently than before we left. They become like water off a duck's back, a fly in the ointment that we just have to deal with. And we move on.
That's where I am at anymore. The horror I faced made me sensitive to the cries and pain of others. The ache to want to help heal the pain is real. The drive to learn and understand not only Torah and Halacha has grown bringing along with it the absolute necessity of understanding our history in order to know why we value and do what we do.
Yes, the time post mikveh started off in the horrors of hell. Yes, I made plenty of mistakes and nearly gave up. And yes, here I am today, completely transformed: no longer resembling the person who went into the waters on 28 Adar 5773. I am quiet, thoughtful, hidden in the background. I am learning with and connected to others that have also trod a similar path. I am here. I am a Jew. I love HaShem, Torah and the true Mitzvot. I am honing my skills and work to give from the best parts of myself back to the world as a whole. I am staying connected. I am filled with hope and confidence that HaShem will continue to mold and make me. It is a tremendous gift that I am grateful to have.

No comments:
Post a Comment